MON's best purchase!

[JerryAV]

Ashley Young for me he is also my favourite villa player.

[BobMarley1945-81 In this bright future, you can't forget your past]

No Heskey in the post

As many have said, very tough but in the end I agree how Jim put it, that for the longevity that Webcams been here and provided teh goods, he gets my nod also.

[herman22]

^^^ I agree with that too! 2nd would be Rich Dunne but the Ash is the best right now!

[BobMarley1945-81 In this bright future, you can't forget your past]

^^^ I agree with that too! 2nd would be Rich Dunne but the Ash is the best right now!

What, why Heskey isn't tehre, I know mate. It's just not on is it

[davesearle]

I said Carew, I figured most would say Ash/Dunne but Carew edges it for me. I think individually Ash would edge it for me, but we got rid of Baros, parted with no money and ended up with Carew...I mean it was perfect!

Its the equivalent of us doing a straight swap of Routledge/Maloney for Ash Young, or swapping Heskey for Huntelaar, brilliant

[JC_VILLA789]

I said Carew, I figured most would say Ash/Dunne but Carew edges it for me. I think individually Ash would edge it for me, but we got rid of Baros, parted with no money and ended up with Carew...I mean it was perfect!

Its the equivalent of us doing a straight swap of Routledge/Maloney for Ash Young, or swapping Heskey for Huntelaar, brilliant

you posted exactly what i was going to say!

In terms of value for money - Carew wins hands down.

[ Post made via Mobile Device ]

[V4Villain]

Petrov's on both lists and not doing well on either lol

[cgale_825]

Petrov's on both lists and not doing well on either lol

that just prooves he`s vaue for money as in we got what we payed for .
But to be a best buy a player must have been of greater value than the price paid

[Hajin]

In time it may well prove to be Delph, at least I hope so, I'm pretty sure I saw something when he was in the side.... but for now it's got to be Ashley, at the time we bought him from Watford I can't remember many other manager climbing over each other to sign him and then put him on the wing.

Great buy

But The Doc's right, Milner would have a few votes if he wasn't on his way out

[TanserMan]

For me Carew.

To think he replaced Baros is amazing, so much better and such a nice guy to boot.

[rustynutz]

Dunne for the price we paid , and the job in replaceing Laursen it has to be him . Also i agree if Milner wasn't "leaving " maybe then he would win this by a mile .

P.S. Where is emily he aint on the list??? , maybe he fell over ,and got injured so he can't make this list . Back on the subs bench again then